It is located in the Pedernales neighborhood. It is the most central neighborhood bordering Miradero to the north and Boquerón to the south. There are many legends about the Cofresí Pirate Cave. There are those who say that Cofresí hid the loot he stole from merchant ships there, but no one has ever found anything. According to the Puerto Rican historian Don Aurelio Tío, Cofresí enjoyed the protection and friendship of a part of the population on the coasts of P.R. with whom the Pirate shared his loot, mainly his family and friends from Guaniquilla and the Morrillos del Faro de Cabo Rojo. To visit this cave it is recommended that you do not go alone and that the people who visit it know it well before venturing out.